On Sale

Carnegie Deli Holiday Cookie Tin Gift Set | 8 Rye Chocolate Chip Cookies

$79.99

As featured in the Goop 2025 Holiday Gift Guide for thoughtful, indulgent gifting.
New York Rye Chocolate Chip

Celebrate the season with a taste of New York tradition. Our New York Rye Chocolate Chip Cookies are a modern take on a 1930s classic, baked with layers of rich 55% dark chocolate, rye flour, real butter, and a hint of sea salt. With crunchy sweet edges and a rippled, golden brown and chewy center, these giant cookies embody everything you love about an old-fashioned bakery treat, elevated the Carnegie way.

Packaged in our Signature Holiday Tin, this nostalgic keepsake features a hand-drawn illustration of the original 1937 Carnegie Deli storefront, accented with festive winter snowflakes—a timeless nod to our roots in the heart of Manhattan. Inside, you’ll find eight oversized cookies, baked with love and ready for gifting, sharing, or savoring all season long.

A New York classic, beautifully wrapped for the holidays.

All of our products are made in a bakery that processes and contains nuts.

      Contents

      • (8) Carnegie Deli Giant Rye Chocolate Chip Cookies
      • (1) Signature Carnegie Deli Holiday Tin
      • Each cookie is approximately 4.5 inches in diameter

      Instructions / Storage

      Our product stays fresh for up to 21 days at room temperature and can be frozen for up to six months. There’s no need to refrigerate it—just be sure to store it away from direct heat or sunlight to keep the chocolate at its best.

      Shipping

      • Check out our Shipping Policy here to know when your order will ship
      • Free Shipping on all continental US Orders Over $125!
      • Orders to Alaska & Hawaii will have FedEx Overnight Air calculated at checkout
      • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes

      Nationwide Shipping

      Award Winning

      Family Recipe

      Whaddya Think?