Join Our Mailing List Stay in Touch for Specials!
|| Paused

Catering Menu

Crudité

Fresh Vegetable Platter

A cool approach to appetizers ̶ broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, celery, radishes, and cherry tomatoes on a bed of crisp iceberg lettuce served with our famous special dip.

Fresh Fruit, Cheese & Crackers

Everyone’s Favorite!

A scrumptious platter of cheeses from around the world together with an assortment of fresh fruit and crackers.

Carnegie's Famous Smoked Fish Platter

A Traditional Brunch That Can Be Enjoyed Anytime!

A platter of freshly smoked whitefish, thinly sliced Novie, Baked Salmon and Lake Sturgeon garnished with crisp iceberg lettuce and our own special cream cheese. A second platter of crisp iceberg lettuce, garden fresh tomatoes and sweet Bermuda onion. A third platter of bagels, bialys and dinner rolls.

Carnegie's Famous Specialties

Stuffed Cabbage – Romanian style served in sweet and sour sauce. 12 large pieces per pan.

Blintzes – Carnegie’s famous assorted homemade blintzes. Choose from cheese, strawberry, cherry or blueberry. Accompanied by apple sauce and sour cream. 12 per pan.

Stuffed Derma – Carnegie’s  own made stuffed derma delicately broiled and covered with superb brown gravy. 12 large pieces per pan.

Gefilte Fish – Our own Gefilte Fish served with sharp horseradish. 12 pieces per pan.

Potato Pancakes – A traditional favorite served with apple sauce and sour cream. 12 per pan.

Potted Brisket of Beef – Served in rich brown gravy. Serves 8.

Chopped Liver  – Carnegie’s own made chopped liver available in any mold, beautifully garnished, decorated and surrounded by crackers or bread. 3 pound minimum.

Potato Pirogen – Fried or boiled pirogen served with sour cream. 25 pieces per pan.

Soups

Our delicious homemade soups. Chicken with matzo balls, noodles, kreplach, kasha or fresh rice. Includes 8 matzo balls on the side.

Hot or cold Russian style Borscht, served with boiled potato and chopped vegetables.

Carnegie's "Subsational" Sandwich

3″, 4″, 5″, 6″ Foot Heroes

Consists of Pastrami, Corned Beef, Turkey, Roast Beef, Salami, Bologna, Ham, American and Swiss. Garnished with Cole Slaw, Pickles, Peppers and Olives and served with Russian Dressing.

Carnegie's Famous Sloppy Joes

Unbelievable 4 Layer Sandwiches

This remarkable platter is made up of various CARNEGIE specialties which include combinations of Tongue, Turkey, Pastrami, Corned Beef and Fresh Brisket, Cole Slaw and Russian Dressing. 8 cuts per sandwich.

Having A Picnic?

Great Outdoor Fun for Friends & Family

Selections include a famous CARNEGIE single meat sandwich, choice of potato salad or cole slaw, cookies and a soda. Paper service and utensils included, all beautifully boxed.

The Magnificent 10 Person Buffet Platter

Professionally decorated platters accompanied with 2 pounds of homemade cole slaw, 2 pounds of fresh potato salad, assorted sours, a tray of rye bread and dinner rolls, and of course, mustard, Russian dressing and mayo on the side.

Carnegie’s Best – Includes your choice of any 4 pound assortment of the following: Freshly baked white meat Turkey breast, Rare Roast Beef, N.Y.’s #1 Smoked Pastrami, our specially cured 1st cut Corned Beef, superbly pickled Tongue and Fresh Brisket of Beef.

N.Y.’s Finest – Includes your choice of any 4 pound assortment of the following: Imported Boiled Ham, Freshly Roasted Virginia Ham, CARNEGIE’S own salami, delicious Bologna, Imported Liverwurst, the finest American cheese, Imported Muenster cheese, Finlandia Swiss cheese.

Tempty Salad Platter

Includes 1 Pound of Each of the Following:

Chunky Chicken Salad, Freshly Steamed Shrimp Salad, The Greatest Chopped Liver, White Meat Tuna Salad, and Freshly Chopped Egg Salad

The Incomparable Party Sandwich Platter

Your choice of any assortment of the following gargantuan sandwiches on a professionally decorated tray and cut in thirds. Also includes cole slaw, potato salad, assorted pickles and of course, mustard, Russian dressing and mayo.

Roast Beef, Ham and Swiss, Chopped Liver, Corned Beef, Pastrami, Egg Salad, Turkey, Salami, Tuna Salad, Tongue, Bologna, Chicken Salad, Brisket, Liverwurst, Shrimp Salad

Salads

Tossed Salad

Fruit Salad

Cole Slaw or Potato Salad

Relish

Unbelievable Desserts

Baked Fresh Daily on the Premises Your taste buds will throw a party for your mouth! Assorted Cheesecake, Cake & Pie Platter $12.50 per slice.

Our Famous Cheesecake

Classic Plain Chocolate, Fresh Strawberry, Fresh Blueberry, Cherry, Chocolate Rugelach, Truffle Torte, Cheesecake of the Month

Cakes & Pies

Chocolate Mousse, Babka, Fudge Layer Apple, Strudel, Carrot Cake, Cherry Strudel, Coconut Layer, Pumpkin Pie, Strawberry Shortcake, Mile High Apple Pie, Black Forest, Pecan Pie, 7-Layer

Cream Pies

5th Avenue, Chocolate, Coconut, Lemon Chiffon, Banana

Coffee & Tea Set-Ups

20-25 cups per gallon. Set up includes milk, sugar, sweetener, paper cups and stirrers, spoons and napkins.